Nearly 300 Estes Valley students got a firsthand lesson in democracy Tuesday, Nov. 3, casting ballots in a mock general election organized by the League of Women Voters of Estes Park.
The League’s Junior Election drew 289 ballots from students ranging from elementary school through high school, giving young people an opportunity to participate in the electoral process and weigh in on candidates and ballot measures confronting Colorado voters.
The program was coordinated with Estes Park High School and Middle School, the Options program, The Learning Place, the Estes Valley Community Center, and the Estes Valley Library.
High school students cast 133 ballots, while middle school students, including ninth-graders, cast 151. Five ballots came from elementary-age voters.
Students largely favored Democratic candidates in major races, though their votes on several ballot measures revealed differences between age groups.
Hickenlooper, Neguse, and Weiser lead student vote
U.S. Sen. John Hickenlooper won among both high school and middle school voters, receiving 68 high school votes and 82 middle school votes.
His Republican opponent, Mark Baisley, received 23 high school votes and 26 middle school votes. Other candidates drew smaller shares of the vote.
U.S. Rep. Joe Neguse also prevailed in both groups, receiving 76 high school votes and 90 middle school votes. His closest opponent, Kelley Dennison, received 25 high school votes and 53 middle school votes.
In the governor’s race, the Democratic ticket of Phil Weiser and Jessie Danielson Dahlkemper led among both groups, receiving 64 high school votes and 72 middle school votes.
The Republican ticket of Marx and Markert finished second, with 25 high school votes and 34 middle school votes.
High school students voted on the entire ballot, while middle school students voted in the U.S. Senate, U.S. House, and governor’s races, along with Amendment 86.
High school voters weigh in on state and county races
In other statewide contests, high school students favored Gonzales for secretary of state with 61 votes, Bridges for state treasurer with 63, and Griswold for attorney general with 72.
Hooten led the University of Colorado Board of Regents District 2 race with 61 votes.
In legislative contests, Marchman received 67 votes in the state Senate District 15 race, defeating Woodward, who received 39. Smith won the state House District 49 contest with 66 votes to Sheperek’s 41.
In the Larimer County commissioner District 1 race, Atkinson received 57 votes, followed by Roberson with 34 and Fowler with 16.
Forsythe led the county clerk and recorder contest with 73 votes, while Ginal received 66 votes for county treasurer.
One of the closest contests was for county assessor, where Edwards received 28 votes, narrowly defeating Overbeck, who received 27. Bradley received 10 votes.
In uncontested races, Sheriff Feyen received 82 votes, Surveyor Donnelly received 81, and Coroner Hanks received 88.
Students divided over ballot measures
High school students considered 16 ballot measures, including seven constitutional amendments, seven statewide propositions, and two local tax questions.
They supported Amendments 81, 82, 83, and 84 but rejected Amendments 85, 86, and 87.
Proposition 137 drew the strongest support among the statewide measures, passing 84-29, followed by Proposition NN, 82-34, and Proposition 133, 82-37.
Proposition 135 ended in a 52-52 tie.
On local funding questions, high school students favored Estes Valley Fire Protection District Ballot Issue 6D, which proposed a 0.5% sales tax to support firefighting equipment, training, wildfire response, and other district needs. The measure passed among high school voters, 60-47, or 56.1%.
Students rejected Larimer County Ballot Issue 1A, a proposed countywide sales tax increase, 60-52.
One notable difference between age groups involved Amendment 86, which set approval requirements for mid-decade congressional redistricting.
High school students narrowly rejected the measure, 56-54, while middle school students supported it, 87-64.
The contrasting results illustrate how students of different ages can reach different conclusions when considering the same ballot question.
Judicial retention votes produce mixed results
High school students also weighed in on 10 judicial retention questions, supporting the retention of eight judges and opposing two.
Judge Hood received the strongest support, with 67 votes in favor and 35 against.
Students voted against retaining Judge Lum, 54-45, and Judge Lynch, 54-49.
The remaining judges — Freyre, Harris, Moultrie, Schock, Sullivan, Ellison, and Zehe — received more votes in favor of retention than against.
Even the youngest students participated
Elementary school students voted on simplified ballots at community precinct locations.
Among kindergarten through second-grade participants, one student voted for Baisley for U.S. Senate and Neguse for U.S. House. Another young voter exercised the write-in option throughout the ballot.
Students in grades three through five split their U.S. Senate votes between Baisley and Hickenlooper and cast votes in selected congressional and gubernatorial contests.
Two elementary students also voted in favor of Ballot Issue 6D.
Although elementary participation was limited, the program introduced younger children to the mechanics of voting and the opportunity to make choices on a ballot.
Building the next generation of voters
Estes Park resident Judi Smith and her late husband, Kent Smith, began the Junior Election program in 2016 to introduce young people to voting before they reach the legal voting age, helping them become familiar with candidates, ballot questions, and the responsibility of participating in elections.
While the results have no bearing on the official election, they offer a snapshot of how young Estes Valley residents viewed the candidates and issues on this year’s ballot.
For the 289 students who participated, the election offered something more lasting than a tally of winners and losers: a chance to practice the civic responsibility they will one day exercise as registered voters.
