Today, I had an eye-opening conversation with a friend and colleague—a woman of color, single mother, immigrant turned U.S. citizen, and new to what we call “formal” leadership. She spoke of her powerlessness, of feeling stripped of her strength, reduced to parts that others find useful, discarded when no longer needed.

Bear with me as I dive into a metaphor. Picture a Thanksgiving turkey. Some prefer the thighs, others will only touch the breast meat from the left side, but the carcass—the bones and structure that carried the turkey through its life—is almost always discarded when the meal is finished.

That carcass is what the turkey was before it ended up on our table, before we picked it apart to satisfy our fleeting desires. The essence of the turkey, its life, its journey, reduced to scraps we throw away without a second thought.

I won’t martyr myself by claiming to use every inch of that turkey, bones, carcass, and all. No, I often discard it as fast as I can—seeing the remnants of an animal’s shell makes me uncomfortable.

I’m not an ethical meat eater. I wave and moo at cows in the field, refusing to believe they’re the same creatures I find in the packaged meat section, destined for my summer cheeseburgers. But I do recognize the purpose of the whole turkey, from before it hit my plate to after. And I know I’m guilty of using only the parts I like, discarding what makes me uncomfortable, what I’d rather not confront.

Now that we’re all thinking about mashed potatoes and gravy (and perhaps realizing the plight of vegetarians), let me return to that raw, frightening conversation. My friend, in her bravery, shared her feelings of powerlessness with someone who, by all accounts, belongs to the very group stripping away her power. It dawned on me that my power needs to become powerLESS.

I mentioned earlier that my friend is new to “formal” leadership. But her leadership is only “formal” in the context of white leadership. She has always been a powerful leader within and for her communities. Yet, she is often burdened with being the sole voice for her community.

Why?

As a white woman in leadership, I would never be expected to be the “voice” for all white
women in leadership. Can you, the reader, think of a single person who could be called the voice of the white community?

We, as white folks, are privileged by the nuance and filtration of our communities. White women, white youth, white business leaders, white nonprofiteers, white republicans, white democrats, white soccer lovers, white cilantro haters—each subgroup with its own voice.

But when it comes to people of color, especially women of color, we lump them together, expecting one person to speak for all. And it’s usually someone who has learned to assimilate into our whiteness, doing the unpaid, expected labor of speaking for their entire community.

But when it’s time to allocate resources, create permanent space, or hold the mirror up to ourselves, we start stripping our turkey again, using only the pieces we need in that moment. The rest is thrown out, frozen for later, or left to rot in the back of the fridge.

This conversation with my friend made me realize that as a white woman with power, I am inherently guilty of stripping my sisters of color for the parts I most need when I need them. We expect our sisters of color to build relationships and “report back” on what their communities need.

But have we ever tried to create that community ourselves? Usually, no.

Yet, when it’s time to secure funding, we parade those collected stories, data, and insights as if they’re our own. We say thank you to my friend for doing the work, and then keep the riches to disperse at our will, under the guise of “helping them manage.” We take what we need and discard what doesn’t serve us.

The powerLESSness of whiteness requires us to sit down, shut up, and be less—for once. To lessen our power so we can elevate the power of those who have been deemed lesser in the white context of our lives. It’s not just about listening sessions or DEI classes—it’s about genuinely lessening the power we hold.

This isn’t a call for symbolic gestures or performative allyship. It’s a call to recognize that our voices have dominated the conversation for far too long, often drowning out the voices that need to be heard most. It’s about stepping back and creating space—real, meaningful space—where the voices of women of color, like my friend, can not only be heard but can lead without the shadow of whiteness looming over them.

My friend is a POWERFUL woman of color, a POWERFUL mother raising her children, a
POWERFUL navigator of bureaucracy, a POWERFUL leader. She possesses a power that I will never have—a power rooted in resilience, in a history of survival against the odds, in a depth of experience that I can only begin to comprehend. Her power doesn’t need to be validated by me or by any white gaze. It exists on its own terms, in its own right.

My friend’s power is hers alone, and it’s time I stop assuming that, as white folks, we have any role in shaping or defining it. My role is to witness, support, and stand alongside her in solidarity—not as a savior, but to ask, “Do you need me to listen in silence? Do you need me to use my voice to amplify yours? Do you need me to fight and shield you from the blows?”

To be powerLESS is to grasp that true power isn’t about control; It’s about the realization that my power has always been borrowed, built on the backs of those like my friend who were never given the chance to claim their own.

To be powerLESS is to be free from the illusion of supremacy and to find strength in the power of others. It is to watch my friend become powerFULL.

Cato Lawson Kraft (she/her) is your typical millennial who loves a good avocado toast with a heaping side of equal rights. She sees “EP” as standing for “Every Person” and understands that embracing our roles in ongoing inequity is tough, often because it’s unintentional. Committed to being her best self while accepting the inevitable fumbles, Cato is passionate about harnessing collective power of ALL to drive real, transformative change.

3 replies on “Realizing the powerLESS role of my whiteness”

  1. Does this immigrant woman live in Estes Park- or just the author?
    I’d like to hear from her directly.
    Of course all Americans know marginalization is wrong- in any venue, going to any ethnicity or people group!
    America is the most giving and generous nation in the world!
    I don’t see a lot of people trying to break OUT of America.
    But I do see powerful “people of color” eg. millionaires and billionaires.
    Oprah Winfrey, Michelle Obama, Candace Owens, and Dr. Ben Carson are just a few, of the many, who come to mind!
    I for one find this article race baiting and divisive.
    Commentator is posting a conversation going to a “woman of color”; that the commentator allegedly had a conversation with- while she {commentator} concurrently uses a broad brush to assign, generalize and paint all “white” persons as racist aggressors- and telling “white” folk to “sit down and shut up!”
    Author has no idea whom her audience is- but she has enough evidence to publicly state that they {whites} mistreat immigrants “of color” turned citizens?
    Interesting that this commentary pops in time for the election… as every four years; the same narrative is trotted out!
    And in between elections- the media {yes even in Estes Park} ignores the reality of pockets of abuse; going to the disabled and other marginalized groups in this valley… of #all color and economic status.
    Yet no few speak up on their behalf!
    Silence IS a language.
    Inequity should not be tolerated in any season!
    *******************
    So-when do we see commentaries posted going to Prospect Living Center and COVID?
    The Asian couple whom construction planners blocked access {to their eatery}?
    The Library who marginalizes Conservatives- but allows everyone else to meet?
    The Library who put handicapped restrooms on the second floor- while
    access was tight in the only elevator to get to the second floor?
    The Library who allowed a male to threaten a female patron because he thought her movement disorder was offensive?
    Law Enforcement Deputy who buddied up with a realtor {he did evictions with}- who allegedly issued threats to an out of Town realtor?!
    The League of Women Voters who should be a Dem PAC?
    Restorative Justice who hosted a police impersonator in their Community Circle?
    My list of those harmed- is substantiated; and draws from nearly every ethnic group and profession in Town including white folk who were victims.
    Point is that while exposing alleged discrimination and marginalization- one needs to make sure they are not engaging in the same behavior by engaging in generalizations going to one specific group!
    Is choosing to publish “white” shaming commentaries the hill the @estesvalleyvoice chooses to die on?

    1. The Estes Valley Voice welcomes civil dialogue on topic of interest and concern to members of the community. Members of the community are welcome to submit both letters to the editor and longer opinion commentary essays. The Estes Valley Voice reserves the right to edit submissions for brevity as appropriate and to also not publish submissions that include vulgarities or hate speech, and yet as defenders of the First Amendment and the cherished right to free speech, we will not attempt to censor speech. We encourage our readers to express their opinions respectfully when disagreeing with the opinions of others. The publication of letters and commentaries does not mean that the opinion expressed is that of the Estes Valley Voice. Patti Brown, Editor

  2. I applaud Cato Lawson Kraft’s article entitled ” Realizing the powerLESS role of my whiteness”. There is so much I don’t and can’t appreciate about the stories and lives of people of color.
    I am privileged to have friends among several strong and brave women of color whose voices need to be heard — without my voice interfering. I’m afraid I may have done exactly that. But, as Cato advises, it’s time for people like me, who care but can’t possibly understand, to “sit down, shut up, and be less” It’s also time to listen deeply, watch with truly open eyes, and admire the journeys, long journeys that so many of our sisters of color have traveled. And to be in awe.

Comments are closed.